double grilled cheese burger five guys guide for hungry fans

Some burger fans want a bun. Others want their bun to be made of grilled cheese. That second group is the reason the double grilled cheese burger five guys fans talk about keeps getting ordered at counters where it never appears on the printed menu.

At The Menu Vault, we hear about this build from readers who spotted it in a friend’s order and wanted to know if it was real. It is real in the sense that many stores will make it when you describe it clearly, but the double grilled cheese burger five guys order is not an official menu item with a button of its own on the register.

Availability varies by store, staff training varies by shift, and a busy lunch line is not the best moment for a long speech at the register. When you keep the request simple, the double grilled cheese burger five guys build stops sounding like a secret code and starts sounding like a normal custom order.

This guide walks through what the item is, what goes inside it, how to order it without confusion, what it usually costs, how it tastes, and the tweaks that regulars use to make it their own. You will also find links to the wider menu, so you can compare this heavy build with lighter choices before you commit. If you are new to the chain, start with the Five Guys hub and the main Five Guys secret menu page, then come back here when you are ready for the full breakdown of the double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich.

What Is the Item: double grilled cheese burger five guys basics

Start with the plain picture. The double grilled cheese burger five guys build takes two grilled cheese sandwiches and uses them as the bun around two beef patties. Each side of the sandwich is a full grilled cheese, with its own bread and its own melted cheese, turned so the cheesy side faces the patties in the middle.

That means the bite stacks up in layers. On the outside you get golden bread that was cooked on the grill until crisp at the edges. Many fans describe the double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich as a double cheeseburger that swapped its soft bun for something richer, crunchier, and far more filling.

Because it is unofficial, there is no single house recipe that every location follows in the same way. One store may build it exactly as described, with two full grilled cheese sandwiches as the outer layers. The double grilled cheese burger five guys name describes the idea fans share with each other, not a promise printed above the counter.

It also helps to know what this item is not. It is not a light lunch, it is not a cheap trick to get extra food for the price of a plain sandwich, and it is not a test of how much the kitchen will give away. You pay for the grilled cheese base and for the added patties, plus any paid extras you pick. Seen that way, the double grilled cheese burger five guys order is fair to the store and satisfying for you, which is exactly why it has lasted as a word of mouth favorite.

What Is In It

The ingredient list is short on paper and big on the tray. Bread, cheese, beef, heat, and your chosen toppings do all the work, and the double grilled cheese burger five guys version doubles down on almost every part of that list.

The Grilled Cheese Buns

The so called buns are two grilled cheese sandwiches, and they carry a lot of weight in this build, in every sense. Each one starts as bread layered with cheese and cooked on the flat top until the outside turns golden and the inside turns soft and melted. When those two sandwiches become the top and bottom of the double grilled cheese burger five guys stack, they bring crunch, butter toasted flavor, and a cheese pull at both ends of the bite.

The Two Patties

Inside sit two beef patties, cooked in the chain’s usual fresh, smashed on the grill style. Two patties matter here because a single patty can get lost between two full grilled cheese sandwiches. Fans who order the double grilled cheese burger five guys build often say the second patty is what turns a fun idea into a full meal that needs no side to feel complete, though plenty of people order fries anyway out of habit and happiness.

Cheese and Toppings

Cheese shows up in the grilled cheese layers and with the patties, so expect a deep, melty middle rather than a thin slice that vanishes. That is the charm of the double grilled cheese burger five guys plate, and it is also why topping choices matter more than usual. Grilled onions and grilled mushrooms lean into the warm, savory side and make the sandwich taste closer to a diner melt.

Sauces need a light hand. Mayo adds smoothness, ketchup adds sweetness, mustard adds a sharp edge, and hot sauce adds heat that helps balance the cheese. Because the double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich is already rich, one sauce is often plenty, and two can turn the middle slippery. You can browse the wider sandwiches price page and the burgers price page to see how this custom build compares with the standard items it borrows from.

How to Order

Ordering is the part that makes some fans nervous, but it should not. The crew does not need a secret name, a wink, or a long story. The double grilled cheese burger five guys request works best when you start with the base item the kitchen already knows, then add the patties, then name your toppings.

Use this wording at the counter. Say, please, I would like a grilled cheese with two patties added inside. That short script covers the whole double grilled cheese burger five guys build, and it avoids the confusion that comes from leading with a fan nickname the staff may not use in that store.

Step by step, the order sounds like this in practice. First, ask for a grilled cheese. Second, ask for two burger patties added to it. Third, say which cheese and toppings you want, and say plainly if you want the toppings grilled or fresh. Said in that order, the double grilled cheese burger five guys request takes about ten seconds and leaves little room for a mix up at the grill.

Politeness is not a small detail here. This is a custom build that asks the kitchen to combine items in a way that is not on the board, so a friendly tone and a little patience go a long way. If the store says it cannot make the double grilled cheese burger five guys version on that day, accept the answer with grace and order the closest build they offer, such as a grilled cheese with one patty or a double cheeseburger on a toasted bun. Availability varies by store, and a good regular is the person the crew is happy to help next time.

Timing helps too. A quieter part of the day, away from the peak lunch rush, gives the team more room to handle a custom order with care. If you are ordering for a group, keep the custom builds to one or two sandwiches rather than asking for five different inventions at once. You can check Five Guys happy hour notes and the chain’s menu prices page before you go, so price and timing questions are settled before you reach the counter.

What It Usually Costs

There is no single set cost for this sandwich, and any page that gives you one firm figure for the whole country is guessing. The double grilled cheese burger five guys build is priced as a combo of menu items, starting from the grilled cheese and adding the cost of two patties, plus paid toppings such as bacon if you choose them. Free toppings, where the store offers them as part of a burger build, will not move the total in the same way, but upcharges vary by location and can change over time.

As a planning guide, most fans find the total usually between $14 and $19 for the sandwich on its own, before fries and a drink. In higher cost cities, or with paid extras added, the sandwich total is usually between $17 and $22. A full meal with fries and a drink is usually between $20 and $27, depending on the fry size and the market. Treat those figures as a range to budget with, not as a quote from the register.

The double grilled cheese burger five guys order can still make sense on value if you split it or if it replaces a burger and a side you would have bought anyway. It is a lot of food in one wrapper. Many first timers finish half, wrap the rest, and reheat it later in a dry pan, where the bread crisps up again in a few minutes. For current price context across the menu, the menu prices pillar and the fries price page give a helpful sense of what sides and extras add to a tray.

Taste

The first thing you notice is the crunch. The outside of the bread is toasted and firm, then your teeth reach soft melted cheese, then hot beef. That contrast is why the double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich has fans who order little else once they try it. A standard bun is soft from the first bite to the last. This build keeps a crisp edge all the way through, especially if you eat it soon after it comes off the grill and do not let it steam in a closed bag on a long drive home.

Flavor wise, cheese leads and beef answers. The grilled cheese layers bring a buttery, toasted taste that wraps around the patties, and the patties bring salt, beef, and juice. With fresh toppings, the double grilled cheese burger five guys bite stays bright enough to finish. With only cheese, beef, and bread, it can feel heavy by the halfway mark, which is why many regulars add pickles or raw onion even if they skip everything else. A sharp, fresh note in the middle keeps the richness from turning flat.

Texture changes as you eat, and that is part of the fun. The top stays crisp longest, the bottom softens as it catches the juices, and the middle stays melty and loose. The double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich is messy in the best diner sense, so keep napkins ready and do not plan to eat it while wearing your best white shirt. Fries help here too, not just as a side but as a break between bites, and the drinks price page is worth a look if you like a cold, fizzy pause with something this rich.

Variations and Tweaks

Once you know the base build, small changes let you tune it to your appetite. None of these tweaks change the spirit of the sandwich, and each one starts from the same double grilled cheese burger five guys idea of grilled cheese layers around beef. Change one thing at a time on your first few orders, so you learn which version is actually your version, rather than building a tower you cannot finish.

Single Patty Version

The single patty version keeps the two grilled cheese sandwiches but uses one patty in the middle. It eats lighter, costs less, and lets the toasted bread and cheese lead. For many people this is the smart first try, because you learn the flavor without the full weight. Fans call it a training size for the double grilled cheese burger five guys build, and there is no shame in liking it better, since the balance of bread, cheese, and beef can feel cleaner with one patty.

Add Bacon

Bacon adds salt, smoke, and a crisp chew that stands up to the soft cheese. It is a paid extra at most stores, so the added cost is usually between $1 and $3 depending on the location. Ask for the bacon well cooked if you like it crisp, since crisp bacon holds its texture inside a hot, melty sandwich far better than soft bacon does. In a double grilled cheese burger five guys order, bacon works best with a fresh topping such as lettuce or tomato to keep the bite from leaning too salty.

Grilled Onions and Mushrooms

Grilled onions bring sweetness and grilled mushrooms bring a deep, earthy note, and together they push the sandwich toward steakhouse flavors. This is the tweak to pick if you want warmth and depth rather than crunch. The double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich with grilled onions and mushrooms tastes rounder and softer, so a dash of hot sauce or a few pickles on the side can lift it. Ask for both toppings by name, since grilled and raw onions give very different results in the same build.

Patty Melt Style

Patty melt style borrows the habits of the classic diner melt. Keep the toppings simple, go with grilled onions, hold the lettuce and tomato, and let the cheese, beef, and toasted bread do the talking. Some fans ask for the bread to spend a little longer on the grill for a deeper toast. If that idea appeals to you, compare it with the dedicated patty melt page, then decide which melt mood you are in. A patty melt leaning double grilled cheese burger five guys order is rich, soft in the middle, and best eaten at a table rather than in a car.

Other small tweaks are easy to test. Extra pickles sharpen the middle, jalapenos add heat, and a second sauce on the side lets you change the last bites without drowning the first ones. You can round out a shared tray with cheese fries or well done fries, though with a sandwich this size, one side for the table is often plenty. The dogs price page is also handy if someone in your group wants a smaller main while you go big.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the double grilled cheese burger five guys build an official menu item?

No. It is an unofficial, fan known build made from items the kitchen already sells. That is why you order it by describing the build, starting with a grilled cheese and adding two patties, rather than by asking for it by name alone and hoping the register has a button for it. Some stores know the name, many do not, and the description works at both.

How much does it usually cost?

On its own, the sandwich is usually between $14 and $19 at many locations, and a meal with fries and a drink is usually between $20 and $27. The total for a double grilled cheese burger five guys order moves with your city, your paid extras, and any price changes at that store, so check the board when you arrive and treat online ranges as a guide.

Can I order it with one patty instead of two?

Yes, and many people prefer it that way. Ask for a grilled cheese with one patty added, then name your toppings. The result keeps the toasted, melty frame of a double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich with a lighter middle, a lower cost, and a finish you can manage without a long break halfway through.

What toppings work best on it?

Pickles, raw onion, lettuce, and tomato are the most useful toppings because they add crunch and a fresh edge against the cheese and beef. Grilled onions and mushrooms are the best pick for a warmer, deeper flavor. Most fans of the double grilled cheese burger five guys build use a mix, a fresh topping for bite and a grilled topping for depth, with one sauce rather than three.

Will every store make it?

Not always. Availability varies by store, by shift, and by how busy the kitchen is at that moment. If a store cannot make a double grilled cheese burger five guys sandwich that day, ask what close build they can do, such as a grilled cheese with one patty or a double cheeseburger with extra cheese. A polite ask and a ready backup plan will serve you well at any location.

Is it good reheated the next day?

It can be, if you reheat it the right way. Use a dry pan on low heat or a hot oven, and let the bread crisp again while the cheese melts through. A microwave makes the bread soft and the middle uneven, so save that for true hunger and low standards. Leftover halves of a double grilled cheese burger five guys order also work well cut into smaller pieces and shared as a snack, which sounds odd until you try it warm.

Keep Exploring

There is more to try once this heavy favorite is crossed off your list. The full secret menus collection covers fan known builds across many chains, the happy hours pillar tracks timing based deals, and the The Menu Vault home page is the fastest way back to the start. Within this chain, the parent secret menu page groups the builds in one place, so you can plan your next order before hunger makes the choice for you.

Readers at The Menu Vault often move from this sandwich to a lighter custom order, then come back here on a day built for a big lunch. However you plan it, the double grilled cheese burger five guys build rewards a clear order, a patient minute at the counter, and a table with plenty of napkins. Order it by describing the build politely, pay for the parts you asked for, and enjoy one of the most talked about fan creations on the menu board that never was.